Circus 2.0

My commenters are obsessing over the woes of STFC as usual, but I can’t quite get in the swing of it.   Instead, I am enjoying two weeks of astro-geekery. First up was the .Astronomy Conference in Cardiff; then a workshop in Cambridge to work out how to take forward the VO agenda in the UK ; and this coming week, the twice yearly VOTECH meeting.

Various folk have already blogged about .Astronomy  – Stuart Lowe, Chris Lintott, Sarah Askew, and the Master of Ceremonies, Robert Simpson (aka Orbiting Frog)  keeping the twitter going. It was a very virtual meeting, with a distributed audience following the meeting on Ustream, and intercontinental video  talks by Phil PlaitPamela Gay, Alberto Conti and others.  Apparently Alberto invented Google in a bar one evening, or something like that. Highlight for me was learning about the WETI Institute. Their big idea is that there is no point searching for extraterrestrial intelligence. Just wait for it. They have a screensaver you can download. There is no need to be connected to the Internet, because the aliens will find a way to contact you anyway.  Check out the WETI web page. Its a hoot.

Of course everybody under thirty was dead keen on all the Web 2ish things – blogs, twittering, YouTube, Facebook, adding your own stuff to Google Sky and so on. Unlike the old fashioned plain brown Web, Web 2.0 is famously democratic and participatory. Its the people’s Web ! You don’t just read stuff, you change it ! Call me an old cynic, but I’m not so sure. All this stuff relies on an infrastructure provided by a handful of massive corporations. They set the parameters. They can switch it off any time they like. They can change the rules so you can only write about approved subjects. They can do a deal with the FBI. You won’t even know. The illusion of participation is really just a Circus. Every time you update your status on FaceBook thats another five minutes you have avoided thinking about who has the power and why.

But lets not get depressed. Next week Wakeham reports, and we will have such fun.

5 Responses to Circus 2.0

  1. Stuart says:

    I just knew those VO folk were telling the FBI which catalogues I’m looking at 😉

  2. Tony says:

    I’m not sure ‘they’ control this stuff or even care to: the illusion of democratic control stops anyone wondering about who is running the really important stuff like the global economy. It is a bit like religion: if you can fool enough people into believing that stuff they’ll police themselves and others and never question (and will resist the assertion of) the control that TPTB have over them.

    Now back to Twitter…

  3. Is it just me or is there something rather ironic about using Web 2 technology to deride Web 2 technology? 😉

  4. andyxl says:

    Paul – I didn’t say Web 2.0 wasn’t fun and indeed absolutely wonderful; just that we shouldn’t fool ourselves into thinking it strengthens the little man against the big man. Tony – I do agree one shouldn’t overestimate the power of “they”. I didn’t mean that W2 technology is under some sort of grey establishment control – it isn’t. Mostly it is controlled by a handful of companies that happen to have gotten big, but they are actually ineffiicient and unpredictable. People tell me that Twitter keeps going down. If Flickr had all their money invested in Lehmann or whatever, they could collapse – then where are your holiday pics ? In fact this ought to be worrying for governments as much as people. The economy relies on Google now….

  5. […] The e-Astronomer: The Universe, the Internet, and Academic Life […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: